Sputnik India cited unnamed media reports on Tuesday to tweet about Pakistan’s purchase of Russia’s Supercam S350 drones, which The Eurasian Times suggested was announced by their manufacturer at this week’s Army-2024 International Military-Technical Forum outside of Moscow. The latter’s article also referenced Indian intelligence agencies’ claim from three years ago that Pakistan had already been using that company’s Supercam S250 drones to spy on India so there’s a precedent for this latest deal.
These reports were followed the day after by President Putin describing Russian-Pakistani anti-terrorist cooperation as beneficial in his congratulatory message to that country’s leadership on their 78th anniversary of independence. They’ve been carrying out annual joint anti-terrorist exercises since 2016 and exchange intelligence about related Afghan-emanating threats like those from ISIS-K. This suggests that the latest deal is meant to build upon that aspect of existing Russian policy.
The surge in “Pakistani Taliban” (TTP) and separatist Baloch terrorist threats inside of Pakistan since April 2022’s US-backed post-modern coup against former Prime Minister Imran Khan has greatly imperiled regional stability. Russia’s Supercam S350 drones could tremendously improve Pakistan’s intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR) capabilities by helping detect these terrorists and their hideouts, however, therefore facilitating anti-terrorist operations that could then reduce the aforesaid threats.
Their manufacturer’s website mentions that these systems can be outfitted with various sensor payloads, but they’re unable to carry weapons, thus meaning that they can’t be threaten Russia’s decades-long strategic partners in India with whom Pakistan has been embroiled in a fierce rivalry. This fact is important to remember since India is very sensitive about Russian-Pakistani military cooperation regardless of the form that it takes so some observers from there might be displeased with this deal.
It was explained last month why “Russia Won’t Meaningfully Enhance Military-Technical Cooperation With Pakistan”, namely because there’s no price that Pakistan could pay to convince Russia to do anything that would risk ruining its strategic ties with India by threatening the latter’s national security. The improvement of Pakistani ISR capabilities for anti-terrorist purposes, even if such systems are sometimes used to monitor the Line of Control (LOC), doesn’t threaten India though.
Nevertheless, this deal is still controversial for other reasons, particularly because The Intercept reported in September 2023 that Pakistan sold shells to Ukraine as part of a quid pro quo with the US for an IMF bailout. Russia either didn’t lend credence to that report and others or it believed – whether naively or not, rightly or wrong, depending on one’s perspective – that the “greater good” of improving Pakistan’s anti-terrorist ISR capabilities outweighs that and thus justifies selling state-of-the-art drones to it.
Whatever its policymakers’ thought process might have been, there’s also the risk that it could ultimately backfire if India alleges that potential future terrorist attacks in its union territory of Jammu & Kashmir were aided to some degree by Pakistan’s use of the Supercam S350 drones. For instance, India might obtain evidence that these systems helped Pakistan detect blind spots along the LOC through which the suspects infiltrated, which could then lead to heavy pressure on Russia to cut off these sales.
Precautionary measures to prevent that could include geofencing the Supercam S350s for use only along the border with Afghanistan, incorporating these terms in their contract, and possibly also allowing Russia the right to remotely monitor these drones’ flight in real time for the duration of their life. If these are undertaken yet India proves that these systems were still misused by Pakistan in the explained scenario, then Russia would have grounds for terminating their deal and ruling out future cooperation.
Altogether, this drone deal is admittedly surprising since few could have predicted that Russia either wouldn’t lend credence to the previously cited reports of Pakistani arms sales to Ukraine or would still bolster its anti-terrorist ISR capabilities in spite of them if they were believed, yet that’s what happened. In any case, the intent is to help Pakistan defend itself from terrorist threats, not gain edge over India along the LOC. The drones can’t carry arms and therefore don’t threaten India’s national security.
